The
hostess of this blog and I go way, way back. Gloria was in two different
writing groups that I taught. The second one operated like a critique group. As
the instructor, I got to make my suggestions first, but everyone else could do
so also.
When I
first started writing with the hopes of being published, I couldn’t find a
critique group so my sister took my chapters to one in her area. They seldom
praised anything, though perhaps she only told me the criticism, and I learned
lots. The critique group I belong to now, I joined way back in 1981. The members have changed over the years, in fact except for the founder, I’m the most consistent attendee. I’ve learned more from this critique group than from any other source including conferences, writing classes and books on writing.
Early on, I learned that the praise was nice but the criticism and suggestions were the helpful part. If I attended and read my pages and didn’t hear what to the other members seemed confusing, or didn’t make sense, or the grammar was flawed, I wouldn’t waste my time.
That doesn’t mean I always agreed with every bit of criticism, but if something was pointed out, I took a long look at it to see how it could be fixed or written more clearly.
I’ve always considered my critique group my first editor. They don’t catch everything, but I’m thankful for what they do point out. Even the paid editor doesn’t find every error, and often not the publisher. In the end, it’s up to me to make sure the work is as error free as possible.
A good critique group can be a valuable asset to your writing journey.
F. M. aka Marilyn Meredith
#13 in
the Rocky Bluff P.D. series, Unresolved Blurb:
Rocky
Bluff P.D. is underpaid and understaffed and when two dead bodies turn up, the
department is stretched to the limit. The mayor is the first body discovered,
the second an older woman whose death is caused in a bizarre manner. Because no
one liked the mayor, including his estranged wife and the members of the city
council, the suspects are many, but each one has an alibi. Copies may be purchased from Book and Table by emailing bookandtablevaldosta@gmail.com with a 10% discount and free shipping as well as all the usual places.
Bio: F. M. Meredith
lived for many years in a small beach community much like Rocky Bluff. She has
many relatives and friends who are in law enforcement and share their experiences
and expertise with her. She taught writing for Writers Digest
Schools for 10 years, and was an instructor at the prestigious Maui Writers
Retreat, and has taught at many writers’ conferences. Marilyn is a member of
three chapters of Sisters in Crime ,
Mystery Writers of America, and serves on the board of the Public Safety
Writers of America. She lives in the foothills of the Sierra. Visit her at http://fictionforyou.com
and her blog at http://marilymeredith.blogspot.com/
Tomorrow, I’m visiting http://paperbackwriter.rebeccaswritingsvcs.com
where you can read a short excerpt.
Thank you, Gloria for hosting me today. I know Gloria is fond of critique groups too. We go back a long way and I'm always happy to visit with her.
ReplyDeleteI agree! Our critique group is the reason we completed our first book and had it published. One difference with our group is that someone other than the writer reads the pages. In this way, we can hear where they stumble or are confused or where the writing is awkward. No one has to accept the suggestions, but when two or more people in the group agree, we always pay attention.
ReplyDeleteEveryone in our group gets a copy of the chapter, so they can write on it, and fix places that I did in my mind but not on paper.
DeleteWhat a great question and thorough answer - thanks, ladies! I agree, a solid critique group is of true value.
ReplyDeleteI really learned a lot from critique group over the years, and I hope I'm helping the newbies in our group.
DeleteExcellent post, Marilyn, as usual. I agree with Lorna about someone other than the author reading the work. I learned early on that the author reads it the way it's supposed to sound, but another reader may come across things the author missed.
ReplyDeleteWe used to do it without anyone getting copies--much harder than how we do it now. Plus folks pick up on different things. I go through each paper one by one when I'm fixing the chapter.
ReplyDeleteThis reminds me how bad I need to get back to my critique group. I got so busy at my day job I couldn't do much of anything. Now that 9-year position was eliminated by new owners. The only upside to this is I definitely have the time.
ReplyDeleteHope you can find a good one, Linda!
DeleteThis post came at a great time--I'm thinking of joining a new critique group next week. I haven't had the benefit of one for a while now, and I miss it.
ReplyDeleteI can't praise my experience enough. Hope it's as good as mine.
DeleteA critique group always find something, even if it's just a misplaced comma or a missing hyphen, so matter how many times I've read it.
ReplyDeleteMy group find lots. LOL
DeleteI'm in two critique groups. It always amazes me how they seem to find/focus on very different things. Best of luck, Marilyn, on the new release.
ReplyDeleteMine meets once a week, don't think I could it in another, but different members find different things to point out.
ReplyDelete